Dividend Stocks vs Mutual Funds: Tips for deciding (2024)

Are you feeling overwhelmed with starting your investment portfolio, and not sure how to choose between Dividend Stocks vs Mutual Funds? Let’s look at each to help you decide what works best for your investing goals.

With so many investment options available you may be unsure where to start. You need to choose which types of investments you will buy, set your investment goals, figure out your risk tolerance.

In the beginning you may not feel confident enough to buy individual stocks. It feels too risky, like you’ll make a mistake. I completely understand as my first few dividend stock purchases didn’t work out as expected.

While mutual funds may feel easier and safer to buy, are they actually better than dividend stocks? Let’s take a closer look mutual funds and dividend stocks to help you decide which you want to hold in your portfolio.

Dividend Stocks vs Mutual Funds: Tips for deciding (1)

One quick note I should mention. I’m not a financial planning professional. I’m sharing what’s working for me as part of my investing strategy. Always do your own research and consider your own circ*mstances before making any financial decisions. You could also check with your favorite financial professional to understand what would be best for your situation.

What are dividend stocks?

Dividend stocks are stocks from individual companies where the company pays out a portion of its profits (or reservers) to the shareholders. Four times a year is the most common payment approach, with some stocks paying twice a year or even once. There are a few stocks that pay monthly, usually a REIT (Real Estate Investment Trust).

By directly holding stock in companies you have control over what you buy and when you sell the shares. This can be seen as more risky because you rely on your own research to guide your decisions.

Typically you’ll own stock in fewer companies than the number of companies held in a diversified mutual fund.

What are mutual funds?

Mutual funds are professionally managed portfolios of investments with guiding rules to determine:

  • the types of companies and industries to include in the portfolio,
  • the types of investments to hold (stocks, bonds, other funds, etc),
  • when to buy new investments, and
  • when to sell those investments.

A mutual fund may focus on companies of a certain size or within a specific industry category. Triggers to buy or sell may be based on a percent gain or loss in value.

The money in the portfolio comes from the cash of participating investors. Mutual funds can give smaller investors, such as us, access to professionally managed portfolios and sometimes investments we could not buy on our own.

The professional management of the fund has staff actively watching the portfolio, doing research, and making decisions based on the fund guidelines and current market conditions.

3 tips for considering Dividend Stocks vs Mutual Funds

Dividend stocks and mutual funds are two different types of investments you could hold in your portfolio. Some mutual funds include dividend stocks in their portfolios. In looking at the three following tips, it will help you consider if you want to directly buy dividend stocks or potentially buy mutual funds containing the same stocks.

Mutual funds have management expenses compared to one-time dividend stock purchase commissions

There are expenses in running a mutual fund. Unless there are account fees, you usually won’t pay any of these fees directly. The expenses can affect the price or capital gains you receive each year. In a highly volatile market year, you might receive a lower amount of dividend or capital gain distributions compared to the previous year.

With long term dividend investing, you usually only pay the initial purchase commission and dividend reinvestment is done without any additional changes. Double check with your brokerage company to confirm any account fees.

Mutual funds may distribute capital gains annually

During the year, certain rules within the mutual fund strategy may trigger the sale shares from the portfolio. The capital gains from the transactions may be distributed out the fund participants (you). If you have the mutual fund in a taxable account, you may need to pay taxes on the income.

With dividend stocks, you would only have capital gains from your shares if you sell them. And similar to mutual funds, taxes on the income may need to be paid if the trade happened in a non-retirement account.

As with all tax questions, double check with your favorite tax professional or the IRS to confirm what applies to your specific situation.

Mutual funds may give you access to special types of investments

In addition to holding stocks, the mutual fund portfolio may also include bonds and other types of investments that are not easily accessible to the regular investor.

A mutual fund focusing on municipal bonds package a tax-exempt offering into a single investment purchase. Corporate bond funds are another type specialized mutual fund that exists.

As a dividend investor, which is better to hold individual stocks vs mutual funds?

You will ultimately need to decide which makes more sense for your portfolio, investment goals, and risk tolerance.

For mutual funds that pay dividends it’s generally not possible to estimate how much you’ll receive each dividend payment. You own shares in the mutual fund, not the specific companies. And in a volatile year, the returns may not be as high as the previous year.

Bond funds may be the exception. The distribution rates may change month to month, but you can get close to estimating the dividends you’ll likely be paid.

With stocks you can lookup the historical dividends as well as future announced payments to estimate how much you might receive based on the shares you hold. Of course the only guaranteed dividend is the one that’s been paid.

While there is nothing wrong with holding mutual funds, as a dividend investor directly holding dividend stocks would give you more control over your portfolio compared to most mutual funds.

Wrapping up. Do you prefer dividend stocks vs mutual funds?

If you’re aiming to be a dividend investor with a planning to grow a dividend portfolio for monthly income, take a look at buying dividend stocks vs mutual funds. With direct stock holdings you can estimate your annual dividends and potentially have lower fees.

To help you get started with researching stocks to buy, check out the holdings of the mutual funds for ideas. I improved my confidence in choosing stocks based on using several mutual funds for hints. If the mutual fund could hold those shares, why couldn’t I?

With each purchase you’ll make decisions based on the information you have at the time, learning more as you go.

Over to you. What types of investment do you think you’ll be buying for your portfolio?

Pin for later

Dividend Stocks vs Mutual Funds: Tips for deciding (2)


As an experienced investor and enthusiast with a deep understanding of the financial markets, I've navigated the complexities of building and managing investment portfolios. Over the years, I've explored various investment vehicles, including dividend stocks and mutual funds, to achieve my financial goals.

In my journey, I've encountered both successes and setbacks, particularly with my initial foray into dividend stocks. I understand the apprehension that comes with taking the plunge into individual stocks, as I, too, faced uncertainties and experienced unexpected outcomes in my early dividend stock investments.

My insights are not only grounded in theoretical knowledge but are shaped by practical experiences. It's essential to acknowledge that I'm not a financial planning professional. Instead, I'm sharing valuable insights into what has worked for me as a part of my investing strategy. I emphasize the importance of conducting thorough research, considering individual circ*mstances, and consulting with financial professionals to make well-informed financial decisions.

Now, let's delve into the concepts presented in the article:

Dividend Stocks:

Definition: Dividend stocks are shares of individual companies that pay out a portion of their profits to shareholders regularly, usually on a quarterly basis. Some may pay dividends monthly, often observed in Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs).

Control and Risk: Holding dividend stocks provides investors with direct control over their investments. However, it is considered riskier as it necessitates reliance on personal research and decision-making.

Mutual Funds:

Definition: Mutual funds are professionally managed portfolios of investments, comprising a mix of stocks, bonds, or other assets. They are guided by specific rules determining the types of investments, industries, and when to buy or sell.

Professional Management: Mutual funds offer the advantage of professional management, where experts actively oversee the portfolio, conduct research, and make decisions based on established guidelines and market conditions.

Tips for Considering Dividend Stocks vs. Mutual Funds:

  1. Management Expenses:

    • Dividend Stocks: Typically involve one-time purchase commissions, with long-term dividend investing requiring minimal additional charges.
    • Mutual Funds: Incur ongoing management expenses that may impact annual returns, particularly in volatile market conditions.
  2. Capital Gains:

    • Dividend Stocks: Capital gains only occur when shares are sold, and taxes apply accordingly.
    • Mutual Funds: May distribute capital gains annually, subjecting investors to potential tax implications.
  3. Access to Special Investments:

    • Dividend Stocks: Offer control over specific companies.
    • Mutual Funds: Provide access to a diversified portfolio, including specialized investments like bonds.

Decision-Making for Investors:

  • Estimating Dividends:

    • Dividend Stocks: Historical and future dividend payments can be researched for estimation.
    • Mutual Funds: Difficult to estimate dividend payments as investors own shares in the fund, not individual companies.
  • Control Over Portfolio:

    • Dividend Stocks: Investors have more control over their portfolio compared to most mutual funds.
    • Mutual Funds: Offer a hands-off approach with professional management.

In conclusion, the decision between dividend stocks and mutual funds depends on individual preferences, investment goals, and risk tolerance. While mutual funds provide diversification and professional management, direct ownership of dividend stocks allows for greater control and potentially lower fees. Ultimately, investors should align their choices with their unique financial objectives.

Dividend Stocks vs Mutual Funds: Tips for deciding (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Last Updated:

Views: 6063

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Birthday: 1993-07-01

Address: Suite 763 6272 Lang Bypass, New Xochitlport, VT 72704-3308

Phone: +22014484519944

Job: Banking Officer

Hobby: Sailing, Gaming, Basketball, Calligraphy, Mycology, Astronomy, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Rev. Leonie Wyman, I am a colorful, tasty, splendid, fair, witty, gorgeous, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.